User:Derik/Sandbox14 - Revision history

Derik at 17:26, 31 July 2009

2009-07-31T17:26:45Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:26, 31 July 2009
Line 2:		Line 2:
	[[Image:TFWIKInet-Optimus.jpg\|120px]]		[[Image:TFWIKInet-Optimus.jpg\|120px]]
	[[Image:Mmc-mf-CC-BY-SA 62.png\|right]]		[[Image:Mmc-mf-CC-BY-SA 62.png\|right]]
			[[Image:Mmc-mf-CC-BY-SA 31.png\|right]]
	{\| style="margin: 0 auto;"		{\| style="margin: 0 auto;"
	\|-		\|-

Derik at 17:26, 31 July 2009

2009-07-31T17:26:14Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:26, 31 July 2009
Line 1:		Line 1:
	{{inprogress}}		{{inprogress}}
	[[Image:TFWIKInet-Optimus.jpg\|120px]]		[[Image:TFWIKInet-Optimus.jpg\|120px]]
			[[Image:Mmc-mf-CC-BY-SA 62.png\|right]]
	{\| style="margin: 0 auto;"		{\| style="margin: 0 auto;"
	\|-		\|-

Derik: /* Content originally licensed under GFDL 1.2 and below */

2009-07-31T00:15:45Z

Content originally licensed under GFDL 1.2 and below

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:15, 31 July 2009
Line 51:		Line 51:

	===MMCs===		===MMCs===
	====Content originally licensed ~~under~~ GFDL 1.~~2 and below=~~===		===Content originally licensed prior to GFDL 1.3===
	In regard to ~~work~~ originally incorporated under ~~GFDL 1~~.2 or ~~earlier~~ that ~~was~~ re-licensed as CC-BY-~~SA3~~.~~... The Licensor asserts that~~		In regard to MMCs originally incorporated under GNU Free Documentation License v1.2 <small>(or a previous version)</small> that have been re-licensed as CC-BY-SA3….

			Given that GFDL is a rigid license whose provisions are not readily open to re-interpretation, we assert that the the platform used by most MMCs (MediaWiki) does, as a ''matter of routine'', render work re-licensed for incorporation from other GFDL MMCs non-compliant with section 4i. (Licensee noncompliance, not licensor.)

	~~GFDL sec 10 paragraph 1~~

			We hold that since 2002, there has been exercised a Common Understanding that MMC content subjected to this non-compliant incorporation is ''not'' cause for termination the GFDL license. (Further, while establishing the specific mechanism by which this Common Understanding may operate is not required for the purposes of this argument… we suggest that it is "probably" exerting some silent function in relation to Section 9 paragraph 2 sub-paragraph b.)

	~~Given~~ the ~~problems MMC's whose purposes other than software documentation~~		We assert that GFDL 1.3’s revisions allowing such MMC’s to "republish" as CC-BY-SA3 without the GFDL are not in conflict with the GFDL forward-compatibility clause <small>(sec 10)</small> stating that future versions of the license "will be similar in spirit." Republishing does not conflict with GFDL’s requirement that that all Modified Versions of a work also be released under "precisely this license" <small>(sec 4, paragraph 1)</small> because a work is not modified in the course of being republished.

	under GFDL~~'s attribution 4b~~,4i - ~~hisrory 4h~~
			Finally, we hold that the revisions in GFDL 1.3 allowing MMC’s to republish themselves outside of the terms and conditions previously allotted by the GFDL represents a good-faith action on the part of the Free Software Foundation’s ''preserve'' those terms and conditions, separate from their obvious right to do so.
			* Allowing the application of the GFDL’s rigid terms to become subject to radical unwritten re-interpretation as a matter of routine in order to accommodate non-compliant MMCs weakens those terms’ ability to guarantee the absolute rights of all work licensed under the GFDL.
			* Altering the terms of the GFDL to allocate special rights for MMCs (which are themselves not generally related to software documentation and have already discarded large portions of the GFDL as inapplicable) would be inconsistent with the GFDL’s provision that all future versions of the license be "similar in spirit," and ill-serve the core base.
			* Migrating MMCs which never belonged under a license designed for the free documentation of software to an equivalent license with compatible terms will offer better long-term protection of those rights than they would have under a diluted or ambigious GFDL.

	===Media Fandom===		===Media Fandom===

Derik: /* mmc-mf Opinion Draft */ still WIPing

2009-07-28T04:46:50Z

mmc-mf Opinion Draft: still WIPing

@@ Line 26: / Line 26: @@
 <div style="margin: 0 auto 0;background-color#efefef;border:solid 1px #999;padding:.5em; 1em;display:table;">This is a non-binding digest of the legal norms of the actual [http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/us/legalcode CC-BY-SA3 Legal Code (the full license)].</div>
 ==<tt>mmc-mf</tt> Opinion Draft==
-Interpellative.
+{|
-Under normal circumstances, the CC-BY-SA3 is ''not'' subject to such interpretation.
+under GFDL's attribution 4b,4i - hisrory  4h
@@ Line 44: / Line 85: @@
 interpretative
 understanding
@@ Line 61: / Line 102: @@
 They transferred it from square peg to square peg... but the second square peg had the ability to deform, so it's ''already'' existing in a trapezoidal form without being formally recognized
 {{note|Unless otherwise specified, section numbers refer to GFDL 1.3 and CC-BY-SA3.  The term MMC and Wiki are used interchangeably here. }}
 ==TFWIKINET-PRODUCER-REMIX==

Derik: 79

2009-07-28T01:57:14Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:57, 28 July 2009
Line 10:		Line 10:
	\|[[Image:Sa icon ccstyle.png\|Share Alike]]		\|[[Image:Sa icon ccstyle.png\|Share Alike]]
	\|-		\|-
	\| colspan="6" style="padding-left:5.~~4em~~;"\|<tt>mmc-mf!CC-BY-SA3</tt>		\| colspan="6" style="padding-left:3.5em;"\|<tt>mmc-mf!CC-BY-SA3</tt>
	\|}		\|}
	~~This~~ work ~~is provided by the licensor~~ under the terms of the [http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/us/legalcode Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 US License Code], or '''<tt>CC-BY-SA3</tt>'''.		The licensor provides this work under the terms of the [http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/us/legalcode Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 US License Code], or '''<tt>CC-BY-SA3</tt>'''.

	The licensor ''further'' presents an Opinion Draft concerning the form assumed by CC-BY-SA3 provisions in relation to Massive Multiauthor Collaborations focused on [[Wikipedia:media fandom\|media fandom]], hereafter referred to as '''<tt>mmc-mf</tt>'''.		The licensor ''further'' presents an Opinion Draft concerning the form assumed by CC-BY-SA3 provisions in relation to Massive Multiauthor Collaborations focused on [[Wikipedia:media fandom\|media fandom]], hereafter referred to as '''<tt>mmc-mf</tt>'''.
Line 72:		Line 72:
	{{note\|Unless otherwise specified, section numbers refer to GFDL 1.3 and CC-BY-SA3. The term MMC and Wiki are used interchangeably here. }}		{{note\|Unless otherwise specified, section numbers refer to GFDL 1.3 and CC-BY-SA3. The term MMC and Wiki are used interchangeably here. }}

	==Content originally licensed under GFDL 1.2 and below==		===Content originally licensed under GFDL 1.2 and below===
	Given the problems MMC's whose purposes other than software documentation		Given the problems MMC's whose purposes other than software documentation

Derik: in progress... no peeking!

2009-07-28T01:53:31Z

in progress... no peeking!

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-{|
+{{inprogress}}
 |-
-|[[Image:Wiki icon ccstyle.png]]
+| colspan="6" style="padding-left:5.4em;"|<tt>mmc-mf!CC-BY-SA3</tt>
 |}
-{{-}}
+This work is provided by the licensor under the terms of the [http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/us/legalcode Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 US License Code], or '''<tt>CC-BY-SA3</tt>'''.
-=mmc-mf!CC-BY-SA3=
-{{-}}
+The licensor ''further'' presents an Opinion Draft concerning the form assumed by CC-BY-SA3 provisions in relation to Massive Multiauthor Collaborations focused on [[Wikipedia:media fandom|media fandom]], hereafter referred to as '''<tt>mmc-mf</tt>'''.
 {|
 |-
-|style="padding: .5em 2em .5em 2em;"|[[Image:Wiki icon ccstyle.png]]|| '''MMC''' — lorem ipsum dolores underwood
+|style="padding: .5em 2em .5em 2em;"|[[Image:Wiki icon ccstyle.png]]|| '''MMC''' — Massive Multiauthor Collaboration
 |-
-|style="padding: .5em 2em .5em 2em;"|[[Image:Fandom icon ccstyle.png]]|| '''Fandom''' — lorem ipsum dolores underwood
+|style="padding: .5em 2em .5em 2em;"|[[Image:Fandom icon ccstyle.png]]|| '''Media Fandom''' —
 |}

Derik: 19

2009-07-27T20:21:51Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:21, 27 July 2009
Line 1:		Line 1:
			{\|
			\|-
			\|[[Image:Wiki icon ccstyle.png]]
			\|[[Image:Fandom icon ccstyle.png]]
			\|style="color:#808080;font-size:60px;"\|!
			\|[[Image:Cc icon ccstyle.png]]
			\|[[Image:By icon ccstyle.png]]
			\|[[Image:Sa icon ccstyle.png]]
			\|}
			{{-}}
			=mmc-mf!CC-BY-SA3=
			{{-}}

	Lorem ipsum, en progressum.		Lorem ipsum, en progressum.

Derik: 6

2009-07-27T19:27:47Z

New page

Lorem ipsum, en progressum.

{|
|-
|style="padding: .5em 2em .5em 2em;"|[[Image:Wiki icon ccstyle.png]]|| '''MMC''' — lorem ipsum dolores underwood
|-
|style="padding: .5em 2em .5em 2em;"|[[Image:Fandom icon ccstyle.png]]|| '''Fandom''' — lorem ipsum dolores underwood
|}

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:26, 31 July 2009
Line 2:		Line 2:
	[[Image:TFWIKInet-Optimus.jpg\|120px]]		[[Image:TFWIKInet-Optimus.jpg\|120px]]
	[[Image:Mmc-mf-CC-BY-SA 62.png\|right]]		[[Image:Mmc-mf-CC-BY-SA 62.png\|right]]
			[[Image:Mmc-mf-CC-BY-SA 31.png\|right]]
	{\| style="margin: 0 auto;"		{\| style="margin: 0 auto;"
	\|-		\|-