Transformers: The Ultimate Guide: Difference between revisions
Deceptitran (talk | contribs) m BOT: replacing (1) links to "Carly" with "Carly Witwicky (G1)" |
Deceptitran (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[Image:Ultimateguide.jpg|right|275px|thumb|He's bigger, faster and stronger too, He's the first member of the DK crew!]] | [[Image:Ultimateguide.jpg|right|275px|thumb|He's bigger, faster and stronger too, He's the first member of the DK crew!]] | ||
'''''Transformers: The Ultimate Guide''''' is an officially licensed guide from [[ | '''''Transformers: The Ultimate Guide''''' is an officially licensed guide from [[DK Publishing]], written by [[Simon Furman]] in 2004 and published in 2005. In 2007, a second edition was published, increasing the page count from 144 to 152 (visibly different by having a reflective background on the cover instead of white). | ||
==Editorial priorities== | ==Editorial priorities== | ||
''The Ultimate Guide'' is one of many similarly titled publications by Dorling Kindersley which cover the histories, characters and worlds of comic characters such as [[ | ''The Ultimate Guide'' is one of many similarly titled publications by Dorling Kindersley which cover the histories, characters and worlds of comic characters such as [[Spider-Man]], the [[Wolverine|X-Men]] and many others. However, the ''Transformers'' tome is distinguished by one major detail—while the other books serve as encyclopedias of the characters' long histories in print, ''Transformers: The Ultimate Guide'' gives only the most basic of treatment to the historical aspects of [[Generation 1 (franchise)|Generation 1]]. Instead, its articles are focused entirely on the then-current [[Dreamwave]] comics [[continuity]]. However, as Dreamwave's universe was so monumentally underdeveloped at the time of the book's publication, most of the information in the book actually had to be created ''for the book''. | ||
Additionally, the book appears to favor deliberately story material from comic continuities as opposed to the [[The Transformers (cartoon)|cartoon]] continuity. This is most conspicuous in dealing with the origin of the [[Dinobot (G1)|Dinobots]] in the Dreamwave universe, where Furman dismisses the notion that they were built on [[ | Additionally, the book appears to favor deliberately story material from comic continuities as opposed to the [[The Transformers (cartoon)|cartoon]] continuity. This is most conspicuous in dealing with the origin of the [[Dinobot (G1)|Dinobots]] in the Dreamwave universe, where Furman dismisses the notion that they were built on [[Earth]] by [[Wheeljack (G1)|Wheeljack]] ([[S.O.S. Dinobots|as in the cartoon]]) on the basis that it is in contradiction with the "historical evidence" that the Dynobots existed on [[Cybertron (planet)|Cybertron]]—from the ''[[The War Within|War Within]]'' comic Furman himself wrote nearly 20 years later. This approach goes so far as to claim that the cartoon's [[Quintesson]]-creation origin for the [[Transformer|Transformers]] is entirely conjectural—when ''talking solely about the cartoon!'' | ||
Finally, in the sections where the book ''does'' deal directly with historical aspects of Generation 1 (in the pages covering the [[The Transformers (Marvel Comics)|Marvel Comics]], the cartoon and the [[The Transformers (toyline)|toys]]), not one page passes without several errors. Several names are spelled incorrectly ("[[Teletraan I (G1)|Teletran-1]]", "[[Carly Witwicky (G1)|Carlee]]", "[[Elita One|Eleta-1]]", "[[Shawn Berger|Sean Burger]]"), various 'toon and comic summaries have inaccuracies in them, and the toys used for images are old, ratty artifacts with peeling, misapplied stickers and various missing accessories. | Finally, in the sections where the book ''does'' deal directly with historical aspects of Generation 1 (in the pages covering the [[The Transformers (Marvel Comics)|Marvel Comics]], the cartoon and the [[The Transformers (toyline)|toys]]), not one page passes without several errors. Several names are spelled incorrectly ("[[Teletraan I (G1)|Teletran-1]]", "[[Carly Witwicky (G1)|Carlee]]", "[[Elita One|Eleta-1]]", "[[Shawn Berger|Sean Burger]]"), various 'toon and comic summaries have inaccuracies in them, and the toys used for images are old, ratty artifacts with peeling, misapplied stickers and various missing accessories. | ||
| Line 21: | Line 21: | ||
* [[Optimus Prime (G1)|Optimus Prime]] | * [[Optimus Prime (G1)|Optimus Prime]] | ||
* [[Megatron (G1)|Megatron]] | * [[Megatron (G1)|Megatron]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Autobot]] Officers | ||
* The [[ | * The [[Decepticons]] | ||
* [[Soundwave (G1)|Soundwave]] and [[Decepticon Mini-Cassette|Co.]] | * [[Soundwave (G1)|Soundwave]] and [[Decepticon Mini-Cassette|Co.]] | ||
* The [[Dinobot (G1)|Dinobots]] | * The [[Dinobot (G1)|Dinobots]] | ||
| Line 34: | Line 34: | ||
* [[Generation 1 (Marvel Comics)|UK Comics 2]] | * [[Generation 1 (Marvel Comics)|UK Comics 2]] | ||
* [[The Transformers (cartoon)|TV Season 3]] & [[The Transformers (cartoon)|4]] | * [[The Transformers (cartoon)|TV Season 3]] & [[The Transformers (cartoon)|4]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Unicron]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Quintessons]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Primus]] | ||
* [[Combiner|Special teams]] | * [[Combiner|Special teams]] | ||
* [[Headmaster (technology)|Headmasters]] and [[Targetmaster|Targetmasters]] | * [[Headmaster (technology)|Headmasters]] and [[Targetmaster|Targetmasters]] | ||
* [[Optimus Prime (G1) toys|Powermaster Optimus Prime]] | * [[Optimus Prime (G1) toys|Powermaster Optimus Prime]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Pretenders]] | ||
* Japanese G1 Toys | * Japanese G1 Toys | ||
* This section deals largely with toys that were [[Pre-Transformer|later recycled into Transformers.]] | * This section deals largely with toys that were [[Pre-Transformer|later recycled into Transformers.]] | ||
| Line 48: | Line 48: | ||
===Generation 2=== | ===Generation 2=== | ||
* Transformers Versus [[ | * Transformers Versus [[G.I. Joe]] | ||
* [[Generation 2 (Marvel Comics)|G2 Comics]] | * [[Generation 2 (Marvel Comics)|G2 Comics]] | ||
* [[Alignment|Beyond G2]] | * [[Alignment|Beyond G2]] | ||
* [[Generation 2 (toyline)|''Generation 2'' Toys]] | * [[Generation 2 (toyline)|''Generation 2'' Toys]] | ||
* [[Megatron (G1)|Megatron]], [[ | * [[Megatron (G1)|Megatron]], [[Pyro]], and [[Clench (G2)|Clench]] are all photographed holding guns that none of them come with. The guns seem to be Hot Spot's. | ||
===Beast Wars=== | ===Beast Wars=== | ||
''Aside from the introduction page, all artwork in the ''[[ | ''Aside from the introduction page, all artwork in the ''[[Beast Wars]]'' and ''[[Beast Machines]]'' sections was provided by [[Mainframe Entertainment]]'' | ||
* [[Beast Wars (Part 1)|The Arrival]] | * [[Beast Wars (Part 1)|The Arrival]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Optimus Primal]] | ||
* [[Megatron (BW)|Megatron]] | * [[Megatron (BW)|Megatron]] | ||
* The [[ | * The [[Maximals]] | ||
* [[Predacon (BW)|Predacons]] | * [[Predacon (BW)|Predacons]] | ||
* [[Beast Wars (cartoon)|TV Season 1]] | * [[Beast Wars (cartoon)|TV Season 1]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Fuzors]] and [[Transmetal]] | ||
* In one caption in this section, [[ | * In one caption in this section, [[Rattrap]] is mislabeled as [[Cheetor (BW)|Cheetor]] | ||
* [[Beast Wars (cartoon)|TV Season 2]] & [[Beast Wars (cartoon)|3]] | * [[Beast Wars (cartoon)|TV Season 2]] & [[Beast Wars (cartoon)|3]] | ||
| Line 72: | Line 72: | ||
===Beast Machines=== | ===Beast Machines=== | ||
* The [[ | * The [[Reformatting]] | ||
* [[ | * [[Maximals]] | ||
* [[Vehicon (BM)|Vehicons]] | * [[Vehicon (BM)|Vehicons]] | ||
* [[Beast Machines (cartoon)|TV Seasons 1 & 2]] | * [[Beast Machines (cartoon)|TV Seasons 1 & 2]] | ||
| Line 80: | Line 80: | ||
===Transformers: Robots In Disguise=== | ===Transformers: Robots In Disguise=== | ||
* [[Robots in Disguise (toyline)|A New Wave]] | * [[Robots in Disguise (toyline)|A New Wave]] | ||
*[[Hightower (RID)|Hightower]] is incorrectly labeled as being a pre-TF ''[[ | *[[Hightower (RID)|Hightower]] is incorrectly labeled as being a pre-TF ''[[Diaclone]]'' design; apparently [[Simon Furman|Furman]] got his "Car Robot"-named lines confused. | ||
* Autobots and Decepticons | * Autobots and Decepticons | ||
| Line 88: | Line 88: | ||
* Autobots | * Autobots | ||
* Decepticons | * Decepticons | ||
* [[ | * [[Mini-Cons]] | ||
* [[Armada (cartoon)|The TV Series]] | * [[Armada (cartoon)|The TV Series]] | ||
* [[Armada (toyline)|''TRANSFORMERS Armada'' Toys]] | * [[Armada (toyline)|''TRANSFORMERS Armada'' Toys]] | ||
| Line 102: | Line 102: | ||
===Dreamwave Comics=== | ===Dreamwave Comics=== | ||
* [[Prime Directive|Generation 1]] | * [[Prime Directive|Generation 1]] | ||
* ''[[ | * ''[[The War Within]]'' | ||
* [[Armada (Dreamwave comic)|''TRANSFORMERS Armada'']] & [[Energon (comic)|''Energon'']] | * [[Armada (Dreamwave comic)|''TRANSFORMERS Armada'']] & [[Energon (comic)|''Energon'']] | ||
| Line 112: | Line 112: | ||
''The Ultimate Guide'' has no doubt been used as a reference by more than a few individuals working on official ''Transformers'' material. Sadly, its influence is always easiest to determine when it causes someone to make a mistake. | ''The Ultimate Guide'' has no doubt been used as a reference by more than a few individuals working on official ''Transformers'' material. Sadly, its influence is always easiest to determine when it causes someone to make a mistake. | ||
The earliest example was the ''[[ | The earliest example was the ''[[Transformers Legends]]'' story, "[[Lonesome Diesel]]", in which an author clearly unfamiliar with Transformers parrotted several of Cybertron's landmarks singled out by the guide, and when listing off the Decepticons, only named those who recieved profiles on the guide's Generation 1 Decepticons page... when the story was supposed to be set ''in the Armada universe''. | ||
The guide's incorrect spellings for "Teletran-1" and "Carlee" (as opposed to "Teltraan I" and "Carly") were carried over into the characters' ''[[Transformers Animated (franchise)|Animated]]'' counterparts, although "Carlee" got corrected in [[The Arrival issue 4|issue 4]] of the ''[[The Arrival|Arrival]]'' comic book. The "Teletran" spelling could well have resulted in [[ | The guide's incorrect spellings for "Teletran-1" and "Carlee" (as opposed to "Teltraan I" and "Carly") were carried over into the characters' ''[[Transformers Animated (franchise)|Animated]]'' counterparts, although "Carlee" got corrected in [[The Arrival issue 4|issue 4]] of the ''[[The Arrival|Arrival]]'' comic book. The "Teletran" spelling could well have resulted in [[Devil's Due]]'s "[[Teletran 3]]" as well. | ||
[[ | [[Roberto Orci]] and [[Alex Kurtzman]] beat tradition by not repeating any of the guide's mistakes when they regularly consulted the guide while writing ''[[Transformers (2007)|Transformers]]''.<a href="http://boards.transformersmovie.com/showthread.php?p=385868#post385868" class="external autonumber" title="http://boards.transformersmovie.com/showthread.php?p=385868#post385868" rel="nofollow">[1]</a> | ||
[[Category:Reference texts]] | [[Category:Reference texts]] | ||
Revision as of 14:33, 24 March 2009
Transformers: The Ultimate Guide is an officially licensed guide from DK Publishing, written by Simon Furman in 2004 and published in 2005. In 2007, a second edition was published, increasing the page count from 144 to 152 (visibly different by having a reflective background on the cover instead of white).
Editorial priorities
The Ultimate Guide is one of many similarly titled publications by Dorling Kindersley which cover the histories, characters and worlds of comic characters such as Spider-Man, the X-Men and many others. However, the Transformers tome is distinguished by one major detail—while the other books serve as encyclopedias of the characters' long histories in print, Transformers: The Ultimate Guide gives only the most basic of treatment to the historical aspects of Generation 1. Instead, its articles are focused entirely on the then-current Dreamwave comics continuity. However, as Dreamwave's universe was so monumentally underdeveloped at the time of the book's publication, most of the information in the book actually had to be created for the book.
Additionally, the book appears to favor deliberately story material from comic continuities as opposed to the cartoon continuity. This is most conspicuous in dealing with the origin of the Dinobots in the Dreamwave universe, where Furman dismisses the notion that they were built on Earth by Wheeljack (as in the cartoon) on the basis that it is in contradiction with the "historical evidence" that the Dynobots existed on Cybertron—from the War Within comic Furman himself wrote nearly 20 years later. This approach goes so far as to claim that the cartoon's Quintesson-creation origin for the Transformers is entirely conjectural—when talking solely about the cartoon!
Finally, in the sections where the book does deal directly with historical aspects of Generation 1 (in the pages covering the Marvel Comics, the cartoon and the toys), not one page passes without several errors. Several names are spelled incorrectly ("Teletran-1", "Carlee", "Eleta-1", "Sean Burger"), various 'toon and comic summaries have inaccuracies in them, and the toys used for images are old, ratty artifacts with peeling, misapplied stickers and various missing accessories.
The episode guides for the Generation 1 cartoon, Beast Wars, Beast Machines, and Armada are also condensed significantly into "best of" guides showcasing the finest episodes, or ones that push the story forward. A Robots in Disguise episode guide was deliberately excluded—leaving that series' section of the book brief and incomplete—in order to leave more room for the then-upcoming Energon line.
Contents
- Introduction
Generation 1
- Cybertron
- The City of Iacon
- Civil War
- Optimus Prime
- Megatron
- Autobot Officers
- The Decepticons
- Soundwave and Co.
- The Dinobots
- Combiners
- TV Season 1
- TV Season 2
- The Movie
- US Comics 1
- US Comics 2
- UK Comics 1
- UK Comics 2
- TV Season 3 & 4
- Unicron
- Quintessons
- Primus
- Special teams
- Headmasters and Targetmasters
- Powermaster Optimus Prime
- Pretenders
- Japanese G1 Toys
- This section deals largely with toys that were later recycled into Transformers.
Generation 2
- Transformers Versus G.I. Joe
- G2 Comics
- Beyond G2
- Generation 2 Toys
- Megatron, Pyro, and Clench are all photographed holding guns that none of them come with. The guns seem to be Hot Spot's.
Beast Wars
Aside from the introduction page, all artwork in the Beast Wars and Beast Machines sections was provided by Mainframe Entertainment
- The Arrival
- Optimus Primal
- Megatron
- The Maximals
- Predacons
- TV Season 1
- Fuzors and Transmetal
- In one caption in this section, Rattrap is mislabeled as Cheetor
Beast Machines
Transformers: Robots In Disguise
- A New Wave
- Hightower is incorrectly labeled as being a pre-TF Diaclone design; apparently Furman got his "Car Robot"-named lines confused.
- Autobots and Decepticons
Transformers Armada & Energon
- Cybertron Revisited
- Autobots
- Decepticons
- Mini-Cons
- The TV Series
- TRANSFORMERS Armada Toys
- The image of Super Mode Optimus Prime has several different paint applications than his general release.
- TRANSFORMERS Energon
- Autobots
- Decepticons
- TRANSFORMERS Energon Toys
- The Energon cartoon did not have a section in the original printing because at the time, it hadn't finished airing.
Dreamwave Comics
Other
- Index
- Acknowledgements
Influence
The Ultimate Guide has no doubt been used as a reference by more than a few individuals working on official Transformers material. Sadly, its influence is always easiest to determine when it causes someone to make a mistake.
The earliest example was the Transformers Legends story, "Lonesome Diesel", in which an author clearly unfamiliar with Transformers parrotted several of Cybertron's landmarks singled out by the guide, and when listing off the Decepticons, only named those who recieved profiles on the guide's Generation 1 Decepticons page... when the story was supposed to be set in the Armada universe.
The guide's incorrect spellings for "Teletran-1" and "Carlee" (as opposed to "Teltraan I" and "Carly") were carried over into the characters' Animated counterparts, although "Carlee" got corrected in issue 4 of the Arrival comic book. The "Teletran" spelling could well have resulted in Devil's Due's "Teletran 3" as well.
Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman beat tradition by not repeating any of the guide's mistakes when they regularly consulted the guide while writing Transformers.<a href="http://boards.transformersmovie.com/showthread.php?p=385868#post385868" class="external autonumber" title="http://boards.transformersmovie.com/showthread.php?p=385868#post385868" rel="nofollow">[1]</a>
