Help:Disambiguation: Difference between revisions

From MediaWiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Steve-o (talk | contribs)
minor reorganization, order-of-appearance for disambig pages
Steve-o (talk | contribs)
updaten, clarifications
Line 2: Line 2:


==Disambiguation methods==
==Disambiguation methods==
The method of disambiguating depends on how many articles there are that need the same title, and their importance:
The method of disambiguating depends on how many articles there are that need the same title, as well as their relative importance.


* If none of the meanings of the term require long definitions, they can all be listed in the same article.
*If there are going to be multiple articles, they should each have a parenthetical qualifier in their titles.
* If there are ''exactly two meanings'' for the term, the primary or more commonly-used meaning should be found in the main article.  The other meaning should be placed in a second article with a clarifying statement in parantheses.  Both articles should include the [[Template:Disambig2]] template to notify readers of the term's other meaning.  (If neither meaning for the term is significantly more prominant, you may create a disambiguation page as described in the final bullet of this list.)
*If there are more than two articles, a disambiguation page must be created.
* If there are ''three or more meanings'' for the term, and ''one of the meanings is significantly more common'' than the other meanings, the most commonly-used meaning should be found in the main article.  The other meanings should be placed in other articles with clarifying statements in parantheses.  A disambiguation page should be created which lists and links to all meanings of the term.  All of the articles should include the [[Template:Disambig3]] template to point readers to the disambiguation page in case they ended up at the wrong page by mistake.
*If one of the terms is significantly more prominent than the other(s), the main page should redirect to it.
* If there are ''three or more meanings'' for the term, but ''none of them is significantly more common'' the the others, the main article itself should be a redirect to a disambiguation page. The disambiguation page should list and link to all meanings of the term.  All of the articles should include the [[Template:Disambig3]] template to point readers to the disambiguation page in case they ended up at the wrong page by mistake.
*If none of the terms are significantly more prominent than the others(s), the main page should redirect to a disambiguation page.
**Even if there are only two articles, if you can't decide which is more important, you should make a disambig page and redirect to it.
*If there is no disambiguation page because there are only two articles and one of them is more important, put [[Template:Disambig2]] at the top of both articles.
*If there is a disambiguation page, put [[Template:Disambig3]] at the top of all articles.
 
Note that if none of the meanings of the term require long definitions, they can simply all be listed in the same article.




==Disambiguation pages==
==Disambiguation pages==


The titles of all disambiguation pages should end with "(disambiguation)".  All disambiguation pages should end with the [[Template:Disambig]] template.
The titles of all disambiguation pages should end with "(disambiguation)".  All disambiguation pages should end with the [[Template:Disambig]] template which places an explanatory box in the article and adds it to the disambiguation page category.


When listing items on a disambiguation page, we generally list them in the order of their first appearance.  Hence, G1 incarnations come first, followed by late Japan-exclusive G1, G2, BW, and so forth.
When listing items on a disambiguation page, we generally list them in the order of their first appearance.  Hence, G1 incarnations come first, followed by late Japan-exclusive G1, G2, BW, and so forth.
Line 23: Line 28:
In those rare instances where a franchise name is not sufficient for disambiguation, there is no single best alternative system.  Simply make the qualifier as brief and clear as possible.  For characters, a faction or subgroup name will usually do the trick if the franchise alone will not; for example, since there are two different characters named "Sky High" within Generation 1, they would be marked "[[Sky High (Pretender)]]" and "[[Sky High (Micromaster)]]".  If the subgroup is exclusive to a particular franchise, as in the case of Sky High, you may omit the franchise name.  In some cases clarity might be improved by including the franchise along with the faction or subgroup.  Use your best judgement.  If others disagree, it will merely mean somebody moves the page later.
In those rare instances where a franchise name is not sufficient for disambiguation, there is no single best alternative system.  Simply make the qualifier as brief and clear as possible.  For characters, a faction or subgroup name will usually do the trick if the franchise alone will not; for example, since there are two different characters named "Sky High" within Generation 1, they would be marked "[[Sky High (Pretender)]]" and "[[Sky High (Micromaster)]]".  If the subgroup is exclusive to a particular franchise, as in the case of Sky High, you may omit the franchise name.  In some cases clarity might be improved by including the franchise along with the faction or subgroup.  Use your best judgement.  If others disagree, it will merely mean somebody moves the page later.


Characters with multiple names (as in the case of alter-egos) should have redirect pages at all names and their article under their most prominent name (hence [[Circuit Breaker]] instead of Josie Beller).  Humans should be listed with their full name if possible (except in the case of alter egos) with redirects from nicknames.
Characters with multiple names (as in the case of alter-egos) should have redirect pages at all names and their article under their most prominent name (hence [[Circuit Breaker]] instead of Josie Beller but [[Donny Finkleberg]] instead of Robot Master).  Humans should be listed with their full name if possible (except in the case of prominent alter egos) with redirects from nicknames.


[[Category:Help]]<div id="wikia-credits"><br /><br /><small>From [http://transformers.wikia.com Teletraan I: The Transformers Wiki], a [http://www.wikia.com Wikia] wiki.</small></div>
[[Category:Help]]<div id="wikia-credits"><br /><br /><small>From [http://transformers.wikia.com Teletraan I: The Transformers Wiki], a [http://www.wikia.com Wikia] wiki.</small></div>

Revision as of 23:42, 3 April 2007

In many cases, more than one article "should" have the same name. Such articles require disambiguation. This article describes our scheme for doing so.

Disambiguation methods

The method of disambiguating depends on how many articles there are that need the same title, as well as their relative importance.

  • If there are going to be multiple articles, they should each have a parenthetical qualifier in their titles.
  • If there are more than two articles, a disambiguation page must be created.
  • If one of the terms is significantly more prominent than the other(s), the main page should redirect to it.
  • If none of the terms are significantly more prominent than the others(s), the main page should redirect to a disambiguation page.
    • Even if there are only two articles, if you can't decide which is more important, you should make a disambig page and redirect to it.
  • If there is no disambiguation page because there are only two articles and one of them is more important, put Template:Disambig2 at the top of both articles.
  • If there is a disambiguation page, put Template:Disambig3 at the top of all articles.

Note that if none of the meanings of the term require long definitions, they can simply all be listed in the same article.


Disambiguation pages

The titles of all disambiguation pages should end with "(disambiguation)". All disambiguation pages should end with the Template:Disambig template which places an explanatory box in the article and adds it to the disambiguation page category.

When listing items on a disambiguation page, we generally list them in the order of their first appearance. Hence, G1 incarnations come first, followed by late Japan-exclusive G1, G2, BW, and so forth.


Disambiguation suffixes

When deciding what to put in parantheses to disambiguate an article title, the first choice should always be the entity's franchise of origin. Multiple-word franchises may use abbreviations while single-word franchises should be written out (as in the Wiki's official franchise identifiers list). Thus the original Ironhide would be Ironhide (G1) and the Unicron Trilogy Ironhide is Ironhide (Energon). If a character/idea/object was introduced in one franchise, and then later fleshed out in another franchise with backstory set before the original introduction, we still use the earliest real-world depiction of the entity, not the earliest in-fiction depiction.

In those rare instances where a franchise name is not sufficient for disambiguation, there is no single best alternative system. Simply make the qualifier as brief and clear as possible. For characters, a faction or subgroup name will usually do the trick if the franchise alone will not; for example, since there are two different characters named "Sky High" within Generation 1, they would be marked "Sky High (Pretender)" and "Sky High (Micromaster)". If the subgroup is exclusive to a particular franchise, as in the case of Sky High, you may omit the franchise name. In some cases clarity might be improved by including the franchise along with the faction or subgroup. Use your best judgement. If others disagree, it will merely mean somebody moves the page later.

Characters with multiple names (as in the case of alter-egos) should have redirect pages at all names and their article under their most prominent name (hence Circuit Breaker instead of Josie Beller but Donny Finkleberg instead of Robot Master). Humans should be listed with their full name if possible (except in the case of prominent alter egos) with redirects from nicknames.