User:Singularity/sandbox: Difference between revisions
Singularity (talk | contribs) |
Singularity (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
drafting [['Til all are one]] section for Live-Action as there's no live-action section, and the words are said in a theater for the first time in thirty-seven years soooo | drafting [['Til all are one]] section for Live-Action as there's no live-action section, and the words are said in a theater for the first time in thirty-seven years soooo<br/>also drafting the director's commentary for [[Transformers (2023) issue 2]] even though i have no time to transcribe an hour of director's commentary. although... part of the stream was just Daniel struggling with his internet speed as his wife and daughter used the bandwith to watch Kids Great British Bakeoff lol | ||
===Live-action film series=== | ===Live-action film series=== | ||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
When the Transwarp Bridge's control panel was destroyed by Scourge in a last resort attempt to ensure Unicron could go to Earth through the Transwarp portal, Optimus Prime realized the only way to close the portal to sacrifice himself to destroy the Transwarp key. Not wanting his allies to be injured when the Key's destruction causes the rest of the Transwarp Bridge to be destroyed, he had the Autobots and Maximals to a safe distance, imploring [[Bumblebee (Movie)#Rise of the Beasts|Bumblebee]] to take Noah and [[Elena Wallace|Elena]] to protect them. Although he initially went along with Bumblebee, Noah doubled back as the Transwarp Bridge fell apart to help Optimus, attempting to hold him down as the collapsing Transwarp portal began to pull everything through it, including Optimus. Prime ordered Noah to let go and to save himself, but Noah refused, shouting "'Til all are one!" as he used [[Mirage (Movie)|Mirage]] in exo-suit mode to try and pull Optimus Prime away from the area. However, as Optimus Prime lost his grip and again was about to be pulled into the portal, [[Optimus Primal (ROTB)|Optimus Primal]] caught his wrist and repeated the "'Til all are one" mantra, pulling him to safety as the three left the volcano.{{storylink|Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (film)|Rise of the Beasts}} | When the Transwarp Bridge's control panel was destroyed by Scourge in a last resort attempt to ensure Unicron could go to Earth through the Transwarp portal, Optimus Prime realized the only way to close the portal to sacrifice himself to destroy the Transwarp key. Not wanting his allies to be injured when the Key's destruction causes the rest of the Transwarp Bridge to be destroyed, he had the Autobots and Maximals to a safe distance, imploring [[Bumblebee (Movie)#Rise of the Beasts|Bumblebee]] to take Noah and [[Elena Wallace|Elena]] to protect them. Although he initially went along with Bumblebee, Noah doubled back as the Transwarp Bridge fell apart to help Optimus, attempting to hold him down as the collapsing Transwarp portal began to pull everything through it, including Optimus. Prime ordered Noah to let go and to save himself, but Noah refused, shouting "'Til all are one!" as he used [[Mirage (Movie)|Mirage]] in exo-suit mode to try and pull Optimus Prime away from the area. However, as Optimus Prime lost his grip and again was about to be pulled into the portal, [[Optimus Primal (ROTB)|Optimus Primal]] caught his wrist and repeated the "'Til all are one" mantra, pulling him to safety as the three left the volcano.{{storylink|Transformers: Rise of the Beasts (film)|Rise of the Beasts}} | ||
{{-}} | {{-}} | ||
===Storytelling notes from Issue 1=== | |||
I'm just temporarily leaving this here as a reference/template for my own storytelling notes from Issue 2.<br/><br/> | |||
As both writer and artist on this ''Transformers'' series, Daniel Warren Johnson has a rare level of creative freedom while composing the issue and using the art to tell the story. Some of these creative choices were covered in a "director's commentary" livestream on his YouTube channel; key insights are reproduced here alongside our own analysis of the issue. | |||
* DWJ keeps a copy of [[IP infringement|Magic Square]]'s "Light of Peace" figure close at hand, which influences his take on Optimus Prime.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=This is the Optimus Prime figure that Magic Square put out this past year in 2023. It's an update, so it has a new head sculpt, it looks just like the movie, the '86 movie which of course has been my bible. He looks so good that you can actually like, kind of pose him, and he looks pretty dynamic. And I knew that, man, if the toy looks this cool in real life, then I can make him look really cool... like look at this, it looks great, he looks kind of alive.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=798s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> He notes that he specifically avoids having Prime's "boots" flare out at all; he tries to draw them perfectly straight.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=Another thing that I'll notice, that I'll give you a little preview of things to come artwise: you'll see Optimus's legs, you know, traditionally, you know, he's got kind of the 1970s design aesthetic here, which I think the Marvel Comics did, where, you know, the leg kind of comes out... like so it makes kind of like a boot cut kind of style for his like lower half of his leg. And I hate drawing that. I hate drawing that. Look how straight these legs are. As this series goes on you're going to see these legs get straighter and straighter. It's a stylistic thing something that I've been kind of like- it's been bugging me about drawing Optimus Prime, and it's just, I cannot stand drawing those legs widening out at the bottom. It's like, something about it, it just like, makes my eyes hurt. I've never liked it in the comics, it always read weird to me that they got wider. Some characters- like I remember when practicing, I was drawing Jazz. Jazz gets really wide, and if it's like, if it's really confident, like big and chunky, or Cliffjumper, big, chunky, no big deal. This? Like, Optimus's legs going wider? It just like, is it going wider is it not going w- anyway these are the ramblings of a crazy lunatic comic book artist.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=2699s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* His primary ''Transformers'' comics influence comes from [[Marvel Comics]] and [[Dreamwave Productions]].<ref>{{citesocial|quote=I wanted to just highlight this poster that I had in my bedroom when I was like 16, when Pat Lee made this imagery. You know, I was a huge ''Transformers'' fan of course when I was growing up, and I read mostly the Marvel Comics, 'cause that was the only thing that was available at the time, and here we have the Pat Lee comics of course that Dreamwave put out. I was so excited, I thought it looked awesome. I still do appreciate its blockiness now. So this is another reason why I wanted to do the project, 'cause like I just remember these feelings, and these like super bright colors that like were so awesome... and just being excited with like every cover, and I just felt like a kid. [...] And of course this image, like this is very satisfying, I knew I didn't want to get this bulbous with the designs, but you know I can't say I wasn't influenced by the absolutely outlandishness of these kind of like larger-than-life characters, so.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=997s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> In the case of the latter, we'll note that [[Prime Directive|their opening miniseries]] prominently featured the ''[[Ark II]]'' disaster which drew heavily from the real-world Space Shuttle ''Challenger'' disaster. | |||
* The first page of the story consists of five vertically-stacked cinematic landscape panels, with Sparkplug's flashbacks interspersed by a panel of the Ark crashing and of Prime's deactivated body. This gives us an idea of what's been going through Sparkplug's mind at the bar. In particular, the panel of Optimus Prime is bookended by Spike's offscreen dialogue getting his dad's attention; Prime is often positioned as something of a father figure in wider pop culture. | |||
** At Hasbro's request, DWJ avoided being too specific as to the conflict being shown.<ref name=HasbroMandates>{{citesocial|quote=So here we've got the first page, and you can kind of see here, Hasbro wanted me to be be very like... don't show what kind of war it is... which is fine, and I did have to change these engines from three engines, which I just thought was a little cleaner, to five engines, like the Ark is, so I didn't think they'd care that much about being on model when it came to the Ark but they did!|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0?t=1316s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
** DWJ wanted to streamline the Ark's design to have just three rear thrusters, but Hasbro insisted on it having five,<ref name=HasbroMandates /> necessitating the digital addition of two more to the later splash page of the ship's engines.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=So again, I had to make a bit of an edit. The original art has just three engines, so I had to add these digitally—which I did not want to do, but Hasbro wanted it, so, okay, you know? It's okay, it's okay, it's all right, it is what it is...|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=1845s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* The second page aims to bring the story into reality,<ref name=Page2>{{citesocial|quote=I really wanted to go all in on the first half of this page, and like really sell to you how lived in this world is. Even though it's a ''Transformers'' book it was very important to me that we got a vibe and a sense of where the human characters come from. And there's nothing more fun, than drawing the heck out of, than like a crappy VW hall. [...] It was a hard thing to draw, but it was also fun. I had to kind of photobash a bunch of different VFW bars—obviously didn't want to take from any one specifically, or any one bar specifically, just kind of taking the best of everything and kind of combining it into one. And this bartender, Danny the bartender, I'm a big fan of, he just kind of stands there. And of course the old guy that maybe has seen something crazy... total shout out to—even his like haircut is the same as, and the hat, as—''{{w|The Iron Giant}}'', so a little shout out there. [...] It doesn't really [take place in a specific time period like the '80s or '90s] in my opinion, there might be other people in the Energon Universe that have a different time, we don't really have a time period in place. I find time periods in comics like ''Transformers'' to be completely unnecessary. If I'm trying to make historical fiction then of course it is important, but when it comes to making things like the Transformers I have just never cared. JFK is not getting assassinated in the background on television here, so it's just not part of the story. But you will notice there's no cell phones, so. But that's cuz I hate writing stories with cell phones in them.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=1406s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> with much more detailed panels of varying shapes and sizes, and a muted earthen color palette. | |||
** DWJ took reference from several different {{w|Veterans of Foreign Wars|VFW}} bars to arrive at the location seen in the comic.<ref name=Page2 /> | |||
** As Spike and Sparkplug exit, the cluttered interior gives way to the orange evening sky, with the generous negative space often physically separating Spike from his distant father. | |||
** DWJ notes that the final panel of this spread is technically wrong; based on the perspective of the scene, Spike should be sinking into the ground. This was necessary so as not to obscure Carly's van,<ref>{{citesocial|quote=I have a bit of a goof, a bit of a mistake [...] if you actually like do the perspective here, the way it should be done, it makes no sense. He would be sinking into the ground, he's like in quicksand right now, but I could not figure out a better dynamic shot choice that would show Carly and her artistic ability with this van. Like I tried to do it like this way, and it didn't really work, because it covered up too much of the van, and I realized just how big he would have to be, like his whole face would have to be like over here and it just didn't work. I wanted him to be in the middle, but then it also didn't make sense. So I was just like beating my head against the wall like, I hope this is okay, I hope people don't notice.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0?si=QxISYwvu5QpUEbhw&t=1516s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> which is the same model of vehicle that appears in DWJ's previous original comic series ''[https://www.skybound.com/murder-falcon Murder Falcon]''.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=Of course the dragon wagon, the van used in ''Murder Falcon''.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=1578s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> Mike Spicer has coloured the van using blue-pink tones, strongly contrasting with the orange otherwise dominating the spread. As we turn the page, these nighttime hues take over the story, marking the beginning of a transition towards the unreal. | |||
* The mountain landscape was drawn to resemble that of an alien planet, to highlight the feeling of "otherworldliness".<ref>{{citesocial|quote=This also is one of my favorite panels in the book. I wanted to start getting a little crazy, a little more intense with the shot choices, to kind of start getting us into the vibe of otherworldliness. This looks a little bit like they're exploring Mars, that was the goal, completely clear sky, really pushing the envelope when it comes to dynamic composition.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=1635s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* As the earthquake begins, we get the first instance of hand-lettered sound effects, drawn into the lineart by DWJ. These appear more prominently and frequently as we transition towards comic-book action. | |||
[[File:TF2023 1 Splash pages composition.jpg|thumb|right|upright=2|Diagram illustrating DWJ's intended flow for the back-to-back splash pages.]] | |||
* The reveal of the Ark is paired across the two-page spread with another splash page of the deactivated Autobots. DWJ hoped to create a seamless transition, with the reader's gaze travelling down towards the inset panels at the bottom left, then following Spike and Carly across to the right, before travelling up into the scene.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=This was a goal, this was the goal: to have these pages be bleeding into each other. [...] You know I don't like to do this very often, you have like two splash pages back-to-back, because they kind of like... it gets a little messy here. But you know I usually like- if I have a big splash here [on the left], I'll usually have something a little more reserved over here [on the right], and I won't have it bleed over to the left side of the page. But with here, you'll actually notice that I was trying to get people to read from... obviously you're reading here, then you go down, left to right, into this bottom part of the page, and have your eye trail up instead of going over here [diagonally across the center fold] to the top. So I was using these kind of inset panels to kind of get you to read that way.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=1985s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> Mike Spicer's coloring (exaggerated in the diagram on the right) again reinforces this intent, with the blue shade of the rocks at the bottom of the right-hand page carrying over from the left-hand page. | |||
** Meanwhile, all of the lines of perspective inside the room point outside, where a tiny Jetfire can be seen approaching. | |||
* Jetfire is one of Robert Kirkman's favorite Transformers, and his role in this series came entirely from Robert Kirkman's broad-strokes outline.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=So, full disclosure: Robert Kirkman came up with the Jetfire idea. Jetfire is one of Robert's favorite Transformers, and that's why he was chosen. He's also like part of the lore and it was kind of like in this big outline that Jetfire was the one that comes in and finds the Autobots on Earth in the Ark- Autobots and Decepticons. But he doesn't have knowledge about the war. So you know I can't give away too much, but that was a Robert Kirkman call, and I was happy to do it. I was a little afraid about drawing Jetfire at first, but I'm actually- of course I write the script first where he dies, because it's just what the story needed, but then as I got to drawing him I was like, "I really like drawing this guy, I'm so sad I have to kill him!"|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=3301s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* The shock death of Bumblebee was a deliberate choice, as DWJ felt like audiences would be getting a little tired of seeing Bumblebee everywhere. Surprisingly, Hasbro felt the same way, and themselves asked if there was a way to write Bumblebee out of the series! DWJ also apparently doesn't enjoy drawing Bumblebee, which informed the decision,<ref>{{citesocial|quote=Let me be totally honest about the Bumblebee page, let me address this. I do really- I do like Bumblebee. I don't like drawing Bumblebee, I don't like those rivets in his arms. That's not the only reason why he had to go, I just honestly wanted to change things up. I just wanted to change things up, and I had seen a lot of Bumblebee, I think we all have, in a lot of ''Transformers'' media, and I just thought it would be a fun little swerve. And this is actually funny, our contact over at Hasbro was also a little tired of seeing Bumblebee everywhere, and he actually asked, before he saw my script, he's like, "is there any way we can not use Bumblebee in the main line?" And I told him, I was like, "I got good news for you!" He had to go, he had to go. Sorry Bumblebee fans, sorry to let you down like that, I am so sorry. They are Transformers, maybe they'll come back... but not for a long time. It's Cliff's time baby! You said it!|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=2545s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> which perhaps doesn't bode too well for Cliffjumper! | |||
* When Starscream turns on Jetfire, DWJ struggled to get the composition exactly right, as he was limited by the need to make it explicitly clear that Jetfire was gravely wounded.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=I wanted to make sure that everybody knew that Jetfire was gravely injured by this blast, which means I couldn't really white it out, had to be clear.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=2498s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* Prime uses several wrestling moves on Starscream; DWJ had previously created the original comic series ''[https://imagecomics.com/comics/series/do-a-powerbomb Do A Powerbomb!]'', which had a central theme of loss—a motif which recurs throughout this first ''Transformers'' issue. | |||
* As Starscream, Skywarp and Thundercracker look identical in black-and-white, DWJ labels them in his lineart so colorist Mike Spicer can easily distinguish.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=Also notice the color notes I had to leave for Mike, because Skywarp and Starcream look exactly alike in black and white.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=2839s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* Prime instinctively knowing about his trailer, and its sudden appearance in the story, is a riff on classic media where Prime's trailer would often appear and disappear out of nowhere per the needs of the story.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=This is a little shoutout to like, the not-making-any-sense of ''Transformers'', where you know, very conveniently, this trailer just shows up out of nowhere. So you know, Prime's like, "What are we going to do?" and he's like, "We could use my trailer!" Look sometimes you just have to have fun and not think too much about the story.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=3131s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* As Prime's face is uniquely inexpressive, DWJ had to get creative to show his emotions to the reader, relying a lot on the character's eyes. Additionally, he tries to channel Prime's feelings through Spike.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=Optimus is a character that does not emote—less so than even the rest of the cast, because of the face shield, because so much of his face is taken up, and he's really only got those eyes to work with. And I found that I was needing a way to channel Optimus through something, and I'm kind of trying to channel that through Spike, if you can't tell. I have a tendency to not be subtle, so... in life and in comics.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=3516s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> When Spike sees Prime kneeling over Bumblebee's body, it seems that he recognises the grief this alien robot is experiencing. | |||
* Amongst the many creative sound effects in this sequence, we have highlights like "GRAPPLE" and "ROLL" accompanying the action. Clicks and buzzes fill the air together with the floating components as the Transformers are reassembled. | |||
* DWJ contrived the situation where Spike and Carly need to push Prime's gun into his reach as a way of giving the human characters agency during the action sequence.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=Sliding the gun! Super fun! I rewrote this scene a few times because the humans were just sitting, screaming, you know? Spike and Carly like, "Oh my god, what's happening!?" behind some rocks, and I was like, "They need to have some agency, they need to get involved somehow." And so that is why I had them push the gun, and it forces action, it just forces movement in a story, it gives Spike personality and like bravery, and I'm very happy with this moment. It's very hard to not just write fight scenes where it's just like fight fight fight fight fight, and finding new ways to tie everybody together, and I wish I had more time to do this but of course we work in genre fiction where there are deadlines, and sometimes that can't happen, but I was glad that I was able to figure this one out.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=3543s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> The "SKRKK" sound effect of the gun scraping along the floor is drawn to follow the lines of action. | |||
* When Prime gives the order to "Transform and roll out!", the ''entire comic'' shifts to a landscape orientation, requiring you to physically turn the comic in your hands. This is awesome. | |||
* Ratchet's updated alternate mode came simply from a dissatisfaction with his classic Nissan look.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=Any reason you went with a more modern style van, a Ford Transit rather than the traditional Nissan Vanette for Ratchet? You know what, I just didn't like the way the Nissan looked, so I just, I really wanted something different. I just wanted something different, so.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=2966s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* DWJ was keen to develop the Decepticons beyond their classic cartoonishly-evil characterisation, with a key example in this issue being Soundwave's clear concern for the injured Ravage.<ref>{{citesocial|quote=It's all about this, baby. It's all about trying to give some... you know... something other than... "The Decepticons are all evil, raah!" Like, Soundwave is a bad dude—but man, he loves his tapes, and one of these tapes is hurting bad and he's feeling real bad about it.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=4410s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> | |||
* For Davey's gruesome death at the hand of Starscream, Hasbro requested it occur off-panel. The beat was intended to clearly set the stakes of the comic without being egregiously gory,<ref>{{citesocial|quote=Hasbro asked for Davey to be killed offscreen, which I was totally fine with. Did want to get kind of messy with it, though, because I did want to kind of make a little bit of a statement. You know, it's a book that your kids can read, but you know, not everybody's going to make it, so.|link=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joUZgObXmU0&t=4593s|name=Daniel Warren Johnson|site=YouTube|title=TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY|year=2023|month=10|day=06}}</ref> and seems to mark a major turning point for Sparkplug. | |||
===Storytelling notes from Issue 2=== | |||
I'm just temporarily leaving this here as a template for my own storytelling notes from Issue 2.<br/><br/> | |||
As with the previous issue, with his role as both artist and writer for this new ''Transformers'' series Daniel Warren Johnson took time to host a "director's commentary" livestream on his YouTube channel to cover some of the creative choices for this issue; key insights are reproduced here alongside our own analysis of the issue. | |||
* Iron Giant connection confirmed | |||
* At first Hasbro first okayed the deer scene, then they started backtracking it. Hasbro was nervous with the deer since they worried it may be misinterpreted as a dark joke. Editor wanted to try a squirrel to tone down the scene, but Daniel fought for it. | |||
* First page was made to invoke rumination with the nature panels | |||
* Daniel used a dinner plate to draw Cybertron's outline | |||
* Beachcomber is one of his favorites, and he "seemingly dies" on the page. He can't say more about that. | |||
* Carly having an airbrush was a way to give her more personality and to give a reason to why Laserbeak chases a heavy metal van | |||
* Daniel will not confirm if the police cars are actually Prowl or not. "maybe in issue 20 maybe never idk" ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ however the un-inked page of Sparkplug driving away from Skywarp and Soundwave as Frosting's F-18D falls out of the sky has the car with a "Prowl" license plate. Hmmmm.... | |||
* It was meant to be Skywarp crushing the cop but Mike miscolored him as Starscream by mistake. They kept it because it's in character. | |||
* Frosting is using an F-18D as Daniel is a fan of the movie Independence Day. | |||
Revision as of 04:15, 29 November 2023
drafting 'Til all are one section for Live-Action as there's no live-action section, and the words are said in a theater for the first time in thirty-seven years soooo
also drafting the director's commentary for Transformers (2023) issue 2 even though i have no time to transcribe an hour of director's commentary. although... part of the stream was just Daniel struggling with his internet speed as his wife and daughter used the bandwith to watch Kids Great British Bakeoff lol
Live-action film series

According to Optimus Prime, there is a belief on Cybertron that the battle against the forces of darkness will continue "'til all are one."
After his distrust of humans led to Scourge taking the two halves of the Transwarp Key to bring Unicron to Earth, Optimus went to apologize to Noah for his mistake. Consoling Noah as he helplessly watched Scourge activate the Key at a distant volcano, Optimus admitted his eons of fighting the Great War led to him losing sight of his belief, as instead of fighting the darkness together with Noah, the two of them have been fighting the darkness independently on their own, creating their distrust. Spurred by his words, Noah resolved to keep fighting, drawing battle plans with Optimus Prime to go against Scourge and the Terrorcons.
When the Transwarp Bridge's control panel was destroyed by Scourge in a last resort attempt to ensure Unicron could go to Earth through the Transwarp portal, Optimus Prime realized the only way to close the portal to sacrifice himself to destroy the Transwarp key. Not wanting his allies to be injured when the Key's destruction causes the rest of the Transwarp Bridge to be destroyed, he had the Autobots and Maximals to a safe distance, imploring Bumblebee to take Noah and Elena to protect them. Although he initially went along with Bumblebee, Noah doubled back as the Transwarp Bridge fell apart to help Optimus, attempting to hold him down as the collapsing Transwarp portal began to pull everything through it, including Optimus. Prime ordered Noah to let go and to save himself, but Noah refused, shouting "'Til all are one!" as he used Mirage in exo-suit mode to try and pull Optimus Prime away from the area. However, as Optimus Prime lost his grip and again was about to be pulled into the portal, Optimus Primal caught his wrist and repeated the "'Til all are one" mantra, pulling him to safety as the three left the volcano.Rise of the Beasts
Storytelling notes from Issue 1
I'm just temporarily leaving this here as a reference/template for my own storytelling notes from Issue 2.
As both writer and artist on this Transformers series, Daniel Warren Johnson has a rare level of creative freedom while composing the issue and using the art to tell the story. Some of these creative choices were covered in a "director's commentary" livestream on his YouTube channel; key insights are reproduced here alongside our own analysis of the issue.
- DWJ keeps a copy of Magic Square's "Light of Peace" figure close at hand, which influences his take on Optimus Prime.[1] He notes that he specifically avoids having Prime's "boots" flare out at all; he tries to draw them perfectly straight.[2]
- His primary Transformers comics influence comes from Marvel Comics and Dreamwave Productions.[3] In the case of the latter, we'll note that their opening miniseries prominently featured the Ark II disaster which drew heavily from the real-world Space Shuttle Challenger disaster.
- The first page of the story consists of five vertically-stacked cinematic landscape panels, with Sparkplug's flashbacks interspersed by a panel of the Ark crashing and of Prime's deactivated body. This gives us an idea of what's been going through Sparkplug's mind at the bar. In particular, the panel of Optimus Prime is bookended by Spike's offscreen dialogue getting his dad's attention; Prime is often positioned as something of a father figure in wider pop culture.
- At Hasbro's request, DWJ avoided being too specific as to the conflict being shown.[4]
- DWJ wanted to streamline the Ark's design to have just three rear thrusters, but Hasbro insisted on it having five,[4] necessitating the digital addition of two more to the later splash page of the ship's engines.[5]
- The second page aims to bring the story into reality,[6] with much more detailed panels of varying shapes and sizes, and a muted earthen color palette.
- DWJ took reference from several different VFW bars to arrive at the location seen in the comic.[6]
- As Spike and Sparkplug exit, the cluttered interior gives way to the orange evening sky, with the generous negative space often physically separating Spike from his distant father.
- DWJ notes that the final panel of this spread is technically wrong; based on the perspective of the scene, Spike should be sinking into the ground. This was necessary so as not to obscure Carly's van,[7] which is the same model of vehicle that appears in DWJ's previous original comic series Murder Falcon.[8] Mike Spicer has coloured the van using blue-pink tones, strongly contrasting with the orange otherwise dominating the spread. As we turn the page, these nighttime hues take over the story, marking the beginning of a transition towards the unreal.
- The mountain landscape was drawn to resemble that of an alien planet, to highlight the feeling of "otherworldliness".[9]
- As the earthquake begins, we get the first instance of hand-lettered sound effects, drawn into the lineart by DWJ. These appear more prominently and frequently as we transition towards comic-book action.

- The reveal of the Ark is paired across the two-page spread with another splash page of the deactivated Autobots. DWJ hoped to create a seamless transition, with the reader's gaze travelling down towards the inset panels at the bottom left, then following Spike and Carly across to the right, before travelling up into the scene.[10] Mike Spicer's coloring (exaggerated in the diagram on the right) again reinforces this intent, with the blue shade of the rocks at the bottom of the right-hand page carrying over from the left-hand page.
- Meanwhile, all of the lines of perspective inside the room point outside, where a tiny Jetfire can be seen approaching.
- Jetfire is one of Robert Kirkman's favorite Transformers, and his role in this series came entirely from Robert Kirkman's broad-strokes outline.[11]
- The shock death of Bumblebee was a deliberate choice, as DWJ felt like audiences would be getting a little tired of seeing Bumblebee everywhere. Surprisingly, Hasbro felt the same way, and themselves asked if there was a way to write Bumblebee out of the series! DWJ also apparently doesn't enjoy drawing Bumblebee, which informed the decision,[12] which perhaps doesn't bode too well for Cliffjumper!
- When Starscream turns on Jetfire, DWJ struggled to get the composition exactly right, as he was limited by the need to make it explicitly clear that Jetfire was gravely wounded.[13]
- Prime uses several wrestling moves on Starscream; DWJ had previously created the original comic series Do A Powerbomb!, which had a central theme of loss—a motif which recurs throughout this first Transformers issue.
- As Starscream, Skywarp and Thundercracker look identical in black-and-white, DWJ labels them in his lineart so colorist Mike Spicer can easily distinguish.[14]
- Prime instinctively knowing about his trailer, and its sudden appearance in the story, is a riff on classic media where Prime's trailer would often appear and disappear out of nowhere per the needs of the story.[15]
- As Prime's face is uniquely inexpressive, DWJ had to get creative to show his emotions to the reader, relying a lot on the character's eyes. Additionally, he tries to channel Prime's feelings through Spike.[16] When Spike sees Prime kneeling over Bumblebee's body, it seems that he recognises the grief this alien robot is experiencing.
- Amongst the many creative sound effects in this sequence, we have highlights like "GRAPPLE" and "ROLL" accompanying the action. Clicks and buzzes fill the air together with the floating components as the Transformers are reassembled.
- DWJ contrived the situation where Spike and Carly need to push Prime's gun into his reach as a way of giving the human characters agency during the action sequence.[17] The "SKRKK" sound effect of the gun scraping along the floor is drawn to follow the lines of action.
- When Prime gives the order to "Transform and roll out!", the entire comic shifts to a landscape orientation, requiring you to physically turn the comic in your hands. This is awesome.
- Ratchet's updated alternate mode came simply from a dissatisfaction with his classic Nissan look.[18]
- DWJ was keen to develop the Decepticons beyond their classic cartoonishly-evil characterisation, with a key example in this issue being Soundwave's clear concern for the injured Ravage.[19]
- For Davey's gruesome death at the hand of Starscream, Hasbro requested it occur off-panel. The beat was intended to clearly set the stakes of the comic without being egregiously gory,[20] and seems to mark a major turning point for Sparkplug.
Storytelling notes from Issue 2
I'm just temporarily leaving this here as a template for my own storytelling notes from Issue 2.
As with the previous issue, with his role as both artist and writer for this new Transformers series Daniel Warren Johnson took time to host a "director's commentary" livestream on his YouTube channel to cover some of the creative choices for this issue; key insights are reproduced here alongside our own analysis of the issue.
- Iron Giant connection confirmed
- At first Hasbro first okayed the deer scene, then they started backtracking it. Hasbro was nervous with the deer since they worried it may be misinterpreted as a dark joke. Editor wanted to try a squirrel to tone down the scene, but Daniel fought for it.
- First page was made to invoke rumination with the nature panels
- Daniel used a dinner plate to draw Cybertron's outline
- Beachcomber is one of his favorites, and he "seemingly dies" on the page. He can't say more about that.
- Carly having an airbrush was a way to give her more personality and to give a reason to why Laserbeak chases a heavy metal van
- Daniel will not confirm if the police cars are actually Prowl or not. "maybe in issue 20 maybe never idk" ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ however the un-inked page of Sparkplug driving away from Skywarp and Soundwave as Frosting's F-18D falls out of the sky has the car with a "Prowl" license plate. Hmmmm....
- It was meant to be Skywarp crushing the cop but Mike miscolored him as Starscream by mistake. They kept it because it's in character.
- Frosting is using an F-18D as Daniel is a fan of the movie Independence Day.
- ↑ "This is the Optimus Prime figure that Magic Square put out this past year in 2023. It's an update, so it has a new head sculpt, it looks just like the movie, the '86 movie which of course has been my bible. He looks so good that you can actually like, kind of pose him, and he looks pretty dynamic. And I knew that, man, if the toy looks this cool in real life, then I can make him look really cool... like look at this, it looks great, he looks kind of alive."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "Another thing that I'll notice, that I'll give you a little preview of things to come artwise: you'll see Optimus's legs, you know, traditionally, you know, he's got kind of the 1970s design aesthetic here, which I think the Marvel Comics did, where, you know, the leg kind of comes out... like so it makes kind of like a boot cut kind of style for his like lower half of his leg. And I hate drawing that. I hate drawing that. Look how straight these legs are. As this series goes on you're going to see these legs get straighter and straighter. It's a stylistic thing something that I've been kind of like- it's been bugging me about drawing Optimus Prime, and it's just, I cannot stand drawing those legs widening out at the bottom. It's like, something about it, it just like, makes my eyes hurt. I've never liked it in the comics, it always read weird to me that they got wider. Some characters- like I remember when practicing, I was drawing Jazz. Jazz gets really wide, and if it's like, if it's really confident, like big and chunky, or Cliffjumper, big, chunky, no big deal. This? Like, Optimus's legs going wider? It just like, is it going wider is it not going w- anyway these are the ramblings of a crazy lunatic comic book artist."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "I wanted to just highlight this poster that I had in my bedroom when I was like 16, when Pat Lee made this imagery. You know, I was a huge Transformers fan of course when I was growing up, and I read mostly the Marvel Comics, 'cause that was the only thing that was available at the time, and here we have the Pat Lee comics of course that Dreamwave put out. I was so excited, I thought it looked awesome. I still do appreciate its blockiness now. So this is another reason why I wanted to do the project, 'cause like I just remember these feelings, and these like super bright colors that like were so awesome... and just being excited with like every cover, and I just felt like a kid. [...] And of course this image, like this is very satisfying, I knew I didn't want to get this bulbous with the designs, but you know I can't say I wasn't influenced by the absolutely outlandishness of these kind of like larger-than-life characters, so."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 "So here we've got the first page, and you can kind of see here, Hasbro wanted me to be be very like... don't show what kind of war it is... which is fine, and I did have to change these engines from three engines, which I just thought was a little cleaner, to five engines, like the Ark is, so I didn't think they'd care that much about being on model when it came to the Ark but they did!"—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "So again, I had to make a bit of an edit. The original art has just three engines, so I had to add these digitally—which I did not want to do, but Hasbro wanted it, so, okay, you know? It's okay, it's okay, it's all right, it is what it is..."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ 6.0 6.1 "I really wanted to go all in on the first half of this page, and like really sell to you how lived in this world is. Even though it's a Transformers book it was very important to me that we got a vibe and a sense of where the human characters come from. And there's nothing more fun, than drawing the heck out of, than like a crappy VW hall. [...] It was a hard thing to draw, but it was also fun. I had to kind of photobash a bunch of different VFW bars—obviously didn't want to take from any one specifically, or any one bar specifically, just kind of taking the best of everything and kind of combining it into one. And this bartender, Danny the bartender, I'm a big fan of, he just kind of stands there. And of course the old guy that maybe has seen something crazy... total shout out to—even his like haircut is the same as, and the hat, as—The Iron Giant, so a little shout out there. [...] It doesn't really [take place in a specific time period like the '80s or '90s] in my opinion, there might be other people in the Energon Universe that have a different time, we don't really have a time period in place. I find time periods in comics like Transformers to be completely unnecessary. If I'm trying to make historical fiction then of course it is important, but when it comes to making things like the Transformers I have just never cared. JFK is not getting assassinated in the background on television here, so it's just not part of the story. But you will notice there's no cell phones, so. But that's cuz I hate writing stories with cell phones in them."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "I have a bit of a goof, a bit of a mistake [...] if you actually like do the perspective here, the way it should be done, it makes no sense. He would be sinking into the ground, he's like in quicksand right now, but I could not figure out a better dynamic shot choice that would show Carly and her artistic ability with this van. Like I tried to do it like this way, and it didn't really work, because it covered up too much of the van, and I realized just how big he would have to be, like his whole face would have to be like over here and it just didn't work. I wanted him to be in the middle, but then it also didn't make sense. So I was just like beating my head against the wall like, I hope this is okay, I hope people don't notice."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "Of course the dragon wagon, the van used in Murder Falcon."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "This also is one of my favorite panels in the book. I wanted to start getting a little crazy, a little more intense with the shot choices, to kind of start getting us into the vibe of otherworldliness. This looks a little bit like they're exploring Mars, that was the goal, completely clear sky, really pushing the envelope when it comes to dynamic composition."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "This was a goal, this was the goal: to have these pages be bleeding into each other. [...] You know I don't like to do this very often, you have like two splash pages back-to-back, because they kind of like... it gets a little messy here. But you know I usually like- if I have a big splash here [on the left], I'll usually have something a little more reserved over here [on the right], and I won't have it bleed over to the left side of the page. But with here, you'll actually notice that I was trying to get people to read from... obviously you're reading here, then you go down, left to right, into this bottom part of the page, and have your eye trail up instead of going over here [diagonally across the center fold] to the top. So I was using these kind of inset panels to kind of get you to read that way."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "So, full disclosure: Robert Kirkman came up with the Jetfire idea. Jetfire is one of Robert's favorite Transformers, and that's why he was chosen. He's also like part of the lore and it was kind of like in this big outline that Jetfire was the one that comes in and finds the Autobots on Earth in the Ark- Autobots and Decepticons. But he doesn't have knowledge about the war. So you know I can't give away too much, but that was a Robert Kirkman call, and I was happy to do it. I was a little afraid about drawing Jetfire at first, but I'm actually- of course I write the script first where he dies, because it's just what the story needed, but then as I got to drawing him I was like, "I really like drawing this guy, I'm so sad I have to kill him!""—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "Let me be totally honest about the Bumblebee page, let me address this. I do really- I do like Bumblebee. I don't like drawing Bumblebee, I don't like those rivets in his arms. That's not the only reason why he had to go, I just honestly wanted to change things up. I just wanted to change things up, and I had seen a lot of Bumblebee, I think we all have, in a lot of Transformers media, and I just thought it would be a fun little swerve. And this is actually funny, our contact over at Hasbro was also a little tired of seeing Bumblebee everywhere, and he actually asked, before he saw my script, he's like, "is there any way we can not use Bumblebee in the main line?" And I told him, I was like, "I got good news for you!" He had to go, he had to go. Sorry Bumblebee fans, sorry to let you down like that, I am so sorry. They are Transformers, maybe they'll come back... but not for a long time. It's Cliff's time baby! You said it!"—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "I wanted to make sure that everybody knew that Jetfire was gravely injured by this blast, which means I couldn't really white it out, had to be clear."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "Also notice the color notes I had to leave for Mike, because Skywarp and Starcream look exactly alike in black and white."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "This is a little shoutout to like, the not-making-any-sense of Transformers, where you know, very conveniently, this trailer just shows up out of nowhere. So you know, Prime's like, "What are we going to do?" and he's like, "We could use my trailer!" Look sometimes you just have to have fun and not think too much about the story."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "Optimus is a character that does not emote—less so than even the rest of the cast, because of the face shield, because so much of his face is taken up, and he's really only got those eyes to work with. And I found that I was needing a way to channel Optimus through something, and I'm kind of trying to channel that through Spike, if you can't tell. I have a tendency to not be subtle, so... in life and in comics."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "Sliding the gun! Super fun! I rewrote this scene a few times because the humans were just sitting, screaming, you know? Spike and Carly like, "Oh my god, what's happening!?" behind some rocks, and I was like, "They need to have some agency, they need to get involved somehow." And so that is why I had them push the gun, and it forces action, it just forces movement in a story, it gives Spike personality and like bravery, and I'm very happy with this moment. It's very hard to not just write fight scenes where it's just like fight fight fight fight fight, and finding new ways to tie everybody together, and I wish I had more time to do this but of course we work in genre fiction where there are deadlines, and sometimes that can't happen, but I was glad that I was able to figure this one out."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "Any reason you went with a more modern style van, a Ford Transit rather than the traditional Nissan Vanette for Ratchet? You know what, I just didn't like the way the Nissan looked, so I just, I really wanted something different. I just wanted something different, so."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "It's all about this, baby. It's all about trying to give some... you know... something other than... "The Decepticons are all evil, raah!" Like, Soundwave is a bad dude—but man, he loves his tapes, and one of these tapes is hurting bad and he's feeling real bad about it."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06
- ↑ "Hasbro asked for Davey to be killed offscreen, which I was totally fine with. Did want to get kind of messy with it, though, because I did want to kind of make a little bit of a statement. You know, it's a book that your kids can read, but you know, not everybody's going to make it, so."—Daniel Warren Johnson, YouTube, "TRANSFORMERS Issue 1 DIRECTOR'S COMMENTARY", 2023/10/06

