Talk:Shrapnel (G1)
Gender Switch note: I see that the trivia says that Shrapnel switched gender "along with Starscream" in Japan. Now, I don't speak/understand/have-ever-watched Japanese TFs, but I did come across this orphaned (until now?) article on Misconceptions and urban legends about Transformers, which says the following:
- Starscream is a female character in the French dub of G1.
-
- This rumor appears to be based on a brief sound clip from the French dub of The Transformers: The Movie, which features a female-sounding voice for Starscream. Some not particularly reliable sources even went so far as claiming that Megatron was referring to Starscream as a "she". However, French fans have since confirmed that Starscream is indeed portrayed as a "male" character in the French dub of the G1 cartoon.
--G.B. Blackrock 20:45, 14 September 2007 (UTC)
I've seen the movie. In French. Countless times. Being French-Canadian and whatnot. He was dubbed as a girl in the movie. Megatron says "Tu es une imbécile!", if he'd referred to a man he would've said "un imbécile". As for Shrapnel, Kickback called him "Mademoiselle Shrapnel", men get called monsieur not mademoiselle. Audio samples here for proof. As for the TV series, both France and Quebec used their own teams to dub this, and Starscream was given a male voice in both. Starscream in Quebec and Starscream in France.
Why did you bring up Japan, though? Did someone else edit the article while I wasn't looking? --Detour 21:30, 14 September 2007 (UTC)
- Sorry. Force of habit. When I talk about foreign TFs, it's almost always about Japanese TFs. This is probably the first time I've ever had occasion to talk about French ones. But I did mean French. I'll leave this for you and Walky to duke it out over on the other thread--G.B. Blackrock 22:43, 14 September 2007 (UTC)
